Menu Sign In Contact FAQ
EuroGA Banner
Welcome to our forums

Learjet 60 N722BD down 2026/11/01

On a different note what can we learn from this?

Ok do not fly in icing and thunderstroms to start with

But once you get for example in a tail stall the usual recommendation is to retract the flaps. But what if no flaps have been deployed to start with?

Then once you get into a steep dive and the elevator is no longer effective due to a high mach number? Power idle and deploy the gear? At this point you have written off the aircraft but the gear might help to slow to a point the elevator becomes effective again? Even if the gear is damaged maybe better land that way later on than to impact the ground.

www.ing-golze.de
EDAZ

I agree the main one is this one

Sebastian_G wrote:

do not fly in icing and thunderstroms to start with

If unsure of position relative to convection, then my criteria is if I find icing at -20C or less then I should not be there, deiced or not deiced.

Antonio
LESB, Spain

The other one is very type-dependant but yes, who cares about gear doors or similar damage if you are accelerating through Vne/Vmo/Mmo?

Many jets will have speed brakes so depending on their operational limitations that would be the first port of call. Does a Lear 60 have speed brakes?

Last Edited by Antonio at 04 Nov 12:09
Antonio
LESB, Spain

@Sebastian_G wrote:

Power idle and deploy the gear?

That’s what one expert was saying…gear can help. In this case no idea if it was possible, or if it would have helped, but it seems like getting some drag out there is a good idea.

@Sebastian_G wrote:

Ok do not fly in icing and thunderstroms to start with

This is the very disappointing part of this story – it seems so preventable. Did this aircraft not have weather info? Why didn’t they just avoid this cell?

Fly more.
LSGY, Switzerland

Sebastian_G wrote:

Power idle and deploy the gear?

There’s also speed brakes on the Learjet.

Last Edited by loco at 04 Nov 12:44
EPPO, LPFR, LSGS, Poland

This kind of accident is not limited to small airplanes or airplanes particularly critical.

I am reminded of this accident:

https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/322115

A Pulkovo Airlines TU154M tried to outclimb a thunderstorm and went into a deep stall. It never regained control.

Now the TU154 is a flying tank and considerably more stable than any Learjet of a jet of this size will ever be. It flies extremely stable, even in manual, even at 35000 ft. Yet this heavy jet was thrown upwards almost 2000 ft within 10 seconds and lost control.

So I’d say yes to

Sebastian_G wrote:

Ok do not fly in icing and thunderstroms to start with

for starters.

I also have misgivings about the airplane itself, as it is one of the cases where a design was simply stretched and enlarged without the wings and tail going with it from the Lear 31. And apparently also the 31 was a handful. This kind of stuff where such designs became from benign to critical for instance was very well documented with planes like the MD11 which had barely enough elevator authority in comparison to the rather benign DC10. That list goes on.

I would be careful criticizing the crew at this stage, particularly the FO who kept doing her duty to the very end. What a shame.

LSZH(work) LSZF (GA base), Switzerland

loco wrote:

I agree with Peter. It is the role of the copilot to challenge decisions and push for safety.

I think this is armchair quarterbacking. There’s no indication here that the copilot didn’t do her job. The only thing we can be sure of is they flew sig sag between thunderstorms but still ended up in what looks to be a bad situation. The exact reason is still unknown though, but it looks more like a freak accident as of now.

The elephant is the circulation
ENVA ENOP ENMO, Norway

For those like me not familiar with the type, this video shows (from min 6) stall behaviour under different normal configurations.



I am surprised by the amount of roll input right at the stall. I was always taught this is a no no and bound to get you into a spin entry…rather use feet. But then maybe the Lear 60 uses spoilers to supplement ailerons for roll control? @loco would know

OTOH I was surprised in the OP by the inability to go back to wings level reporting 60-degree bank angle…

I am trying in my mind to find a link between the above two paragraphs

Pertinent to the OP there are also online comments about the effectiveness (or lack thereof) of a Lear 60’s radar. Are those green areas in the navigation display terrain or radar?

Last Edited by Antonio at 04 Nov 16:56
Antonio
LESB, Spain

LeSving wrote:

I think this is armchair quarterbacking. There’s no indication here that the copilot didn’t do her job. The only thing we can be sure of is they flew sig sag between thunderstorms but still ended up in what looks to be a bad situation. The exact reason is still unknown though, but it looks more like a freak accident as of now.

Which part looks to you like “sig sag between thunderstorms”? The single left turn towards the system instead of away from it or the early descent into the soup and staying in it for 10(?) minutes? How many “request heading xxx for weather” are there in their LiveATC recording?

Last Edited by loco at 04 Nov 17:39
EPPO, LPFR, LSGS, Poland

loco wrote:

Which part looks to you like “sig sag between thunderstorms”? The single left turn towards the system instead of away from it or the early descent into the soup and staying in it for 10(?) minutes?

We don’t know what information was available to them. They certainly saw the storms, but not how they actually developed, and we don’t know what they actually saw. It’s easy in hindsight to sit with all information in the world available and criticize. From what I can see from the video they first deviated S to stay clear of the main storm. Then E and later NE for some reason, flying along the south edge of the main storm. I would guess to prevent going straight into the smaller storms south that were under development. Then they turned straight into a very small one under developing. Why? Perhaps it didn’t look that bad, it was a tiny one after all at that stage at least. She also asked for “a better ride” and was told it would clear up to the east over water and they also started climbing. Then bang.

My point is. There’s a whole lot we don’t know. We don’t know why and how and what about most things leading up to it. We know the route they took, and that the situation seemingly was worse than they anticipated. If it was the storm that took them, which we don’t know yet, it’s only speculations at this point. It might just as well be the autopilot for all we know.

It’s way too early to hand out judgements to the crew. It’s all speculations.

The elephant is the circulation
ENVA ENOP ENMO, Norway
Sign in to add your message

Back to Top