There have been people flying with concrete filled tyres still attached, that lift is easily generated by the wing. And don’t get me started on these cables on the ground, I don’t even know what they’re for – are they supposed to prevent theft?
I’d trust a ground screw over any of those options – you can lift a 40kg concrete tyre, you can’t budge one of these. And in a pinch with an oncoming storm and no way to flee, you can create near infinite tie down force (link in German only, but with pictures
). Yes, if you pull straight up, it’s noticeably less, but still more than enough for the average GA plane.
Inkognito wrote:
There have been people flying with concrete filled tyres still attached, that lift is easily generated by the wing.
I reall a Swedish accident investigation report involving an aircraft that had “taken flight” with concrete tyres attached. The report laconically stated that “aircraft are designed to fly with a load.”
Were those aircraft in Italy tied down? I’d sure hate for my aircraft to experience that kind of wind on the ground – wow!
These tyres are of course a joke (unless it is a tractor tyre) when each wing can hold more weight in fuel than one of such a tyre. Where they are present, there is usually not much else to use, so I use them as well but more out of compliance. In any case, it doesn’t matter if you have perfectly secured you aircraft when all others aren’t and will damage everything that’s in their path.
This kind of events are not unusual in northern italy. On September 2021 a tornado destroyed a few planes and hangars at Carpi ( LIDU). Fortunately my plane was parked on a hangar that was spared by the tornado path!
Clipperstorch wrote:
In any case, it doesn’t matter if you have perfectly secured you aircraft when all others aren’t and will damage everything that’s in their path.
Well you might have much better cards with the insurance claim(s)…
@Sebastian_G wrote:
Well you might have much better cards with the insurance claim(s)…
I agree, insurance is a motivator for me. The tires with concrete in them are not going to keep your aircraft secure during a tornado, but they will keep it from rolling away in “normal” wind under most cases. Better than nothing, for sure.
I use the tyres, too, if nothing else is available in light weather, but if there were a storm approaching, I’d rather ask to park on grass and use the screws.
Beware those screws. My daughter had one of those to tether her horse, and he decided he didn’t like it. He just lifted his head slowly but in a determined way and the screw thing just uncoiled and pulled out of the ground as a piece of wriggly wire.
Of course aviation stuff is made to much higher quality and I once came across a Cessna parked at Wellesbourne with a couple of those. The things had only stretched slightly, still in the ground but enough for the ropes to have become unhooked and left dangling free. The plane hadn’t moved.
In the US, if you walk away from your plane without having first tied it down, you’re liable to have someone point out the error of your ways. Personally I use the ‘claw’, which may or may not perform better, but which definitely ticks a box on the insurance claim form.